Home » Musings

Homework Blogging

10 February 2010 761 views Comments «

Anyone who has ever been on a hike, inebriated late at night, or refreshed early in the morning can tell you that the best conversations cannot be forced. When the air is fresh, the senses focused, the mood right – only at such times will the Muse begin her song.

Classrooms are ill-suited for genuine, in-depth conversations. They are run by one individual, limited by time, crowded, indoor, and the seats are uncomfortable. Members of a classroom are obligated to be there, and most forms of jesting, fighting, and crying are discouraged. The Muse can choose any audience: Why would she sing to such an unnatural and unhappy crowd?

This article is not about the shortcomings of any system of education. For now, I accept that broad-scale education cannot be as inspiring as a walk through the woods or a twilight dialogue. But it can be better than it is right now.

Start small: Students should blog their essays.

They need to be reminded that they are part of this world – not just components of a tiny classroom. Understanding common literary themes is important, because that wisdom helps people live well – not because it will get them good grades. When a student recognizes this, the quality of their writing will improve. The stakes are higher, so they will take more risks and enjoy the work more.

And they will remember. Students forget an assignment after its completion, because the assignment is the only part of the learning process over which they have any control. By preserving an essay, opening it up to discussion with people who have lived some of the lessons about which the student is learning, and removing the grade dynamic, the value of the assignment becomes unpredictable and thus intersting (and thus less temporary).

I firmly believe that a child’s mind expands to fill the space it is allowed. Let’s encourage our students to broaden their worlds and blanket us in the warmth of their brilliance.

«
  • I would love to see kid's learning from each other by blog posts. I think something like idea would allow students minds to be less constrained and encourage creativity rather than stamp it out after going through a school system.
  • That's actually a really cool idea--kids and tweens these days already live such public social lives it would be cool if they felt their schoolwork had some impact on the big, wide world as well.

    At the very least, all their grandparents would read them.
  • Thanks for your comment!

    As I write the followup to this brief post, more and more benefits are becoming clear to me.

    One of my favorites is the new level of transparency that students will gain into other students' work. "As a composer draws inspiration from the music of her contemporaries, so too will students learn from their peers. Observation does not have to foster competition or encourage comparison. There is no way to guess the impact that healthy awareness of others' art might have on one's own, but it doesn't take much imagination to realize that the current practice of students working in silos does them more harm than good."
  • Matthew
    I have known Sumeet to say some pretty wise things, but this really impressed me. I agree that there are certain characteristics about the classroom environment that don't really encourage kids to do much more than the minimum. Giving students an opportunity to share their thoughts with a much large audience seems like it would introduce interesting, if not significantly positive, changes to how the student relates to the project. Getting a comment on an essay you wrote about Shakespeare or some crap could really inspire you. I like the reach of the web. It seems like its always making smart people, like Sumeet, figure out cool ways of using it.
  • Thanks for the comment, Matt. I've been thinking about this subject a lot since writing this, and I'm preparing a longer essay on the matter. After more research and thought, I'll be approaching an actual classroom with the intention of convincing a teach to participate in a pilot program.
blog comments powered by Disqus